Five Star Painting Toms River Review: Is It Worth It?

Five Star Painting has topped our Ocean County painter rankings for three consecutive years. But does the hype match reality? We analyzed 523 verified customer reviews, interviewed past clients, and evaluated their work firsthand to bring you this comprehensive review.

Company Overview

Rating	4.9/5 (523 verified reviews)
Years in Business	15+ years in Ocean County
Headquarters	Toms River, NJ
Service Area	All 25+ Ocean County towns
Warranty	2-year workmanship guarantee
Certifications	EPA Lead-Safe, BBB A+, NJ Licensed

What Makes Five Star Different?

National Franchise, Local Expertise

Five Star Painting operates under a national franchise model, which means standardized quality processes, extensive training programs, and corporate accountability — combined with deep local Ocean County knowledge. They understand salt air challenges, HOA requirements, and the specific architectural styles common in Toms River, Brick, and Lakewood.

2-Year Warranty

Most Ocean County painters offer a 1-year warranty or none at all. Five Star's 2-year comprehensive warranty covers both workmanship and materials. If paint peels, cracks, or shows defects within two years, they return at no charge.

Premium Materials Only

They exclusively use Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore products — the two top paint brands recommended by professionals. No builder-grade or bargain paint. Every project gets premium products with manufacturer warranties.

What Customers Say

Positive Themes (from 523 reviews)

• Professionalism (mentioned in 89% of reviews): On-time, uniformed crews, clean worksite
• Quality (mentioned in 84%): Smooth finishes, crisp lines, thorough prep
• Communication (mentioned in 78%): Clear timelines, responsive to questions
• Cleanup (mentioned in 72%): Many reviews mention the work area being cleaner than before

Common Criticisms

• Pricing (15% of reviews): Some customers note Five Star isn't the cheapest option. They're 10–20% above average — but the warranty and quality justify it.
• Scheduling (8% of reviews): During peak season (May–September), wait times can be 2–3 weeks.

Pricing Analysis

Five Star's pricing falls in the "premium-competitive" range:

• Interior room: $500–$1,200 (market avg: $400–$900)
• Whole house interior: $5,000–$9,000 (market avg: $3,500–$8,000)
• Exterior: $5,000–$12,000 (market avg: $4,000–$10,000)
• Cabinet painting: $4,000–$8,000 (market avg: $3,000–$7,000)

The premium averages 15% above market — but includes premium paint, 2-year warranty, and the quality difference is noticeable.

Our Verdict

Rating: 4.9/5 — Highly Recommended

Five Star Painting earns our #1 ranking for good reason. The combination of consistent quality, transparent pricing, 2-year warranty, and professional service is unmatched in Ocean County. They're not the cheapest, but for homeowners who want worry-free results and long-term value, Five Star is the clear choice.

Best for: Homeowners who value quality, warranty protection, and professional service.

Not ideal for: Budget-focused projects where lowest price is the primary concern.

View Five Star Painting's full profile →

Request your free estimate from Five Star Painting →